Disney has seemed to use the real pocahontas only as loose inspiration rather than an homage to her life with the main parts only kept the same were the names used, ethnicity and geographic location. Started to look for gold when the colonists arrived to jamestown. Are all disney movies, which have the characters from history, have the same story as the. This unofficial subreddit is dedicated to the stories, worlds, and magic of all things disney. Naturally, this disney movie pocahontas 1995, directed by mike gabriel and eric goldberg, takes some liberties with the story, because that is. While pocahontas was a real person as well as many of the characters depicted it should be noted that the. The disney version of pocahontas has many differences from the real story and is highly inappropriate because it turns a tragic story into not one, but two cartoon movies, for children. Like in the movie, she was a part of the powhatan tribe and was the chiefs daughter. Reality the stories of disneys pocahontas and the real pocahontas are not the same. What are the differences and similarities between avatar and. Pocahontas true name was matoaka, which means naughty one or spoiled one. Disney movie vs history film studies essay uk essays. Although it had name of the characters from the history, but the story was not the same as it was in actual history.
You can follow any responses to this entry through the rss 2. In the animated film, it serves as the climax, bringing to head the collision between cultures that has been building up so far in the story. Their stories are not based on european fairy tales, but on the culture of native tribes whose way of life was destroyed by colonisation. The true story of pocahontas as not told by disney. Apr 22, 2017 examining racist tropes in disney animated films. Encyclopedia virginia wrote that pocahontas ended up meeting up with smith when she went to england in 1616. Nov 25, 2015 despite similarities, pocahontas gets love, malinche gets hate. Pocahontas was a nickname, her real name was matoaka. Fourth grade students know about pocahontas, but is this knowledge based on historical fact, or on information from the media, specifically the disney movies pocahontas and pocahontas ii.
Both pocahontas and john smith were young when they met, although in real life, pocahontas was 11 and. The true story of pocahontas as not told by disney ancient. So enough must be known about the real story of pocahontas to. The europeans, puffed up with their notions of civilization, did. Dec 09, 2017 although pocahontas was a real person, the version we know by disney is really only loosely based on the original person mostly using the names, ethnicity and geographic location from her tale. The story of pocahontas has been told in many ways, and the fact that there are so many romanticized versions of her life makes it difficult to distinguish the truth from fiction. The story of pocahontas is one we have all heard and it was made popular by the 1995 disney movie but is the story true. In the movie, pocahontas is seen as a very strong individual, but in the real story was not as. But does the commemorative statue honor her real life. Lastly, disney relates pocahontas to nature in many ways. Spoiler alert avatar, while visually a stunning movie especially in 3d was, at first viewing, a very similar plot to disneys pocahontas which is not historically accurate, but that is for a different post. With using censorship in this movie, disney builds a dramatized and flawed history of pocahontas and illustrates a fake reality of who pocahontas was.
Oct 19, 2015 after exploring the real pocahontas and disneys pocahontas, i do agree with the powhatans in saying that disney should have made there pocahontas more like the real person. The disney pocahontas movie was mostly made up of no facts unlike the second one they remade just for the powhatan tribe which even didnt show in theaters. Governor ratcliffe and chief powhatan where a good representation. The disney version of pocahontas and the real story have many differences such as the romance, pocahontas personality. The very famous disney movie, pocahontas, shows lies about the life of pocahontas that people soon believe as the truth. In the disney movie, pocahontas is a beautiful young adult with courage. Learn about the historic powhatan indian princess pocahontas. The real story of pocahontas is much darker than the disney movie. I saw some similarities between moana and pocahontas.
To expand on this, not only was pocahontas brave in real life but she was also portrayed as brave in the disney. In the movie, pocahontas is seen as a very strong individual, but in the real story was not as brave or noble. Despite similarities, pocahontas gets love, malinche gets hate. Her real name was matoaka, which was the nickname of her childhood. Because of the aforementioned age difference, there was no real romantic. To address this question within the context of the new york state social studies curriculum and the new york state english language arts standards, the author created a critical literacy and history unit of study in which students compared the fictionalized accounts of native american life and the biography of pocahontas as shown in the disney. Malick, after all, is a legendary auteur, while disney is, well, disney. Although it may be true, as smith later said, that pocahontas intervened to save his life, she was only 10 or 11 years old when she made the gesture the film depicts them both as adults. With rich animation and unforgettable music, pocahontas is a funfilled story of friendship and courage. He was found trespassing on native territory and sentenced to death, but pocahontas intervened by placing her head upon his. Pocahontas was an indian girl who met and fell in love with handsome explorer john smith and the two were married.
While the second movie introduced her real husband, john. According to smiths book, the generall historie of virginia, newengland, and the summer isles. Pocahontas for more than two centuries since the death of the indian princess pocahontas, legends and stories of romance have been imbedded into our minds, but her dramatic life was more important to the creation of a segment of american history than legend. Actually, john rolfe a cocky character in disneys second film showed special interest in matoaka. The story of pocahontas has been told in many ways, and the fact that there are so many romanticized versions of her life makes it difficult to. Disneys brazen disregard for the truth immediately irked those familiar with the wellknown story in u. Pocahontas is definitely one of the bravest princesses. Disney heroine pocahontas sparkles with all the colors of the wind in this captivating classic inspired by a reallife american legend. By comparing the disneys pocahontas to her reallife counterpart using four. For example in the disney production pocahontas was the same age as john smith, but in real life pocahontas was twelve when she met john smith. Similarities between pocahontas the movie and real life essay. She was famous for saving life of captain john smith. Comparing the disney image with historical evidence. Kocoum was also a good representation, but something that was wrong was that before pocahontas married john rolfe she was married to kocoum.
I saw some similarities between moana and pocahontas, lets discuss. Difference and similarities between the movie and the real l. Pocahontas met john smith as an adult in the movie while pocahontas was 11 and smith was 28. Disney princesses in wreck it ralph 2 vs original princesses. Mulan is a fun movie, with extremely catchy songs, and traditional animation that meets all of the high standards that disney used to be known for. Then she was engaged to kocoum in the movie while john smith was there but she was engaged to him when john smith went back to england in real life. There are similarities between the history of it and movie, but theres also differences. Both of them falls in love with a blonde captain, which are in mission to kill their race. She was famous for saving life of captain john smith pocahontas. The thing i was most wanted to know has always been whether there was really a relationship between john smith and pocahontas. Favorite answer well, in real life pocahontas was a lot younger, and john smith a lot older, than they are portrayed as being in the film. But her most legendary deed is saving the life of john smith. It captures the spirit of pocahontas, her people and the early days of jamestown. Despite similarities, pocahontas gets love, malinche gets.
Disney s pocahontas in real life pocahontas and john smith were both young adults when they met. The truth behind 5 disney movies that are based on real. Though pocahontas is the only disney princess and protagonist in general to be based on a historical figure, she is only very loosely based on her. History disneys pocahontas is a great movie, but is it historically correct. Both of them are strong, assertive noncaucasian women who runs barefoot. Pocahontas married john rolfe and they had a child thomas rolfe who was born on january 30, 1615. That is kind of like one of us going to the moon, and unfortunately, she perished there as she was preparing to return home. It is about real issues, even if it treats them with naive idealism.
For though stylistically the films are worlds apart, there are uncomfortable similarities in the romanticized history each offers. Pocahontas is remembered as the native american powhatan princess who saved the life of englishman john smith, married john rolfe and fostered peace between english settlers and native americans. Disney movies are famous for fantasy and fairy tales. Though the later movie released had a few modern twists to it, the basic plot is noticeably similar. Jan 11, 2018 this entry was posted on thursday, january 11th, 2018 at 1. The true story of pocahontas history smithsonian magazine. Disney princesses in wreck it ralph 2 vs original movies. They are still based off of a similar place and time in history, which causes them to have certain similarities. Pocahontas, though, was very real, and even made a welldocumented trip to london, england. Statue of pocahontas in historic jamestowne, virginia, usa. Pocahontas was the first animated movie of the disney, which was based on history. Mulan clever mulan disguises herself as a male soldier named ping to bravely take her fathers place in the imperial army.
The true story of pocahontas as not told by disney ancient origins. Pocahontasjohn smith story, would share little in common with disneys 1995 animated feature, pocahontas. The many differences include romance, the character personality of pocahontas, and the ending of the story. Disneys pocahontas, voiced by native actress irene bedard. What are the differences and similarities between avatar. The most easily recognized similarity is of that john smith is in both the movie and narrative. Wikimedia the real story of pocahontas would make a greater movie than the one produced by disney, as her tragic life. There are many similarities between the real story of pocahontas and disneys interpretation of pocahontas. In reallife, pocahontas and powhatan were told he died on his way to england, which was not true. I saw some similarities between moana and pocahontas, lets.
Disneys pocahontas in real life pocahontas and john smith were both young adults when they met. The story of pocahontas disneyfied, or disney tried. In the new world, the pivotal moment happens early in the movie, using it as a touchstone to set into motion all that would happen afterwards in pocahontas life. Pocahontas had an amazing figure, and wore a leather minidress with one shoulder strap. Difference and similarities between the movie and the real life of pocahontas similarities the setting jamestown, virginia started to look for gold when the colonists arrived to jamestown. Pocahontas is the bestlooking of the modern disney animated features, and one of the more thoughtful. Cinderella cinderella has faith her dreams of a better life will come true. Mar 02, 2019 statue of pocahontas in historic jamestowne, virginia, usa.
A similarity of these two stories is that they both capture the spirit of the pocahontas and the first nations. A comparison between disney movie pocahontas free essays. And of course, the fake love story angle between john smith and a tooyoung. After some discussion of the disney version, the children will be sho nwn the live action movie, pocahontas. What is the difference between the disney pocahontas movie and the historical story. Sep 11, 2015 disneys animated story of pocahontas has been viewed by millions of children around the world since the films release in 1995, and remains one of the largest premieres in movie history. If you think about it, pocahontas and esmeralda does share a lot of similarities.
In the movie, pocahontas appears to have been emancipated by smith, the stereotypical and civilized white man. I saw some similarities between moana and pocahontas, let. Although it may be true, as smith later said, that pocahontas intervened to save his life, she was only 10 or 11 years old when she made. Difference and similarities between the movie and the real. To address this question within the context of the new york state social studies curriculum and the new york state english language arts standards, the author created a critical literacy and. Start writing about differences from pocahontas disney and real life with our best example essay. Similarities between pocahontas the movie and real life. Pocahontas might be a household name, but the true story of her short. Disneys animated story of pocahontas has been viewed by millions of children around the world since the films release in 1995, and remains one of the largest premieres in movie history. This justifies a historically negative colonizing period towards native american women.
In its view, native americans lived in peaceful harmony with nature until european settlers came, bringing guns and ecological destruction. Although pocahontas was a real person, the version we know by disney is really only loosely based on the original person mostly using the names, ethnicity and geographic location from her tale. Both of them have headstrong animal sidekicks who helps them and even opposes against the love interest. Pocahontas and her friends find adventure at home and abroad in these sweeping stories from the earliest days of american history. I mean, she did it in front of everyone and her head was about to get chopped off. I never really learned much about her or her life outside of the disney movies. I cant think of a single disney movie which didnt put a twist or two on the source. I took a course in the history of film animation and i remember. Well, in real life pocahontas was a lot younger, and john smith a lot older, than they are portrayed as being in the film. Find out more about compare and contrast pocahontas movie to real life. But here are all the ways that disney changed the real story. Pocahontas the difference and similarities between.
We know so much more about her real life now that native americans are also coming to realize we should talk about. Disney movie insiders disney movie club movies anywhere screen pass. Both pocahontas and john smith were young when they met, although in real life, pocahontas was 11 and john smith was 28. Jun 30, 2015 does disney s pocahontas do more harm than good. In 1995, disney released an artistically beautiful animated film showing the supposed events that unfolded between john smith and pocahontas. This was my personal favorite work of disneys renaissance era bookended by the little mermaid in 1989, and tarzan in 1999. I will always love the film pocahontas and sing pocahontass songs whenever i see a. Jun 18, 2018 disney princesses in wreck it ralph 2 vs original princesses. But what makes mulan the bravest disney princess for me is that she knew there were little chances of making it out alive in the army but she still went through with it. Disney heroine pocahontas sparkles with all the colors of the wind in this captivating classic inspired by a real life american legend. Pictures and quickly made its way from the theaters to the viewers heart as the story was actually inspired by real life happenings. Clever mulan disguises herself as a male soldier named ping to bravely take her fathers place in the imperial army.
825 1346 669 1536 39 1264 1134 1180 414 1008 19 643 59 708 47 755 652 355 363 849 647 585 1384 849 478 1290 1243 713 995 1049 368 668 685 665 94 121 112 344 47 1350 1405 1303 1136 179